Broken Pedal

So I have cheap resin pedals on my commuter. I generally like them, they work well and look fine. However on my take-off from work last night one of the reflectors broke off! I didn't think this would be so bad, but I guess it extended the size of the pedal by about 1cm, which I had grown accustomed to. My whole ride home felt lop-sided. I haven't decided what to do about the pedals yet. Glue them back together, or replace them with an old cheap plastic set or go and get nice new flashy pedals.